Tuesday, June 15, 2010
Check Your Facts, Border Coalition Tells Iowa Rep.
June 15, 2010
by Juan Aguilar
The Texas Border Coalition, a group of elected officials and business leaders, today asked a Republican congressman whose district is hundreds of miles from the border to keep his ignorance in check.
U.S. Rep. Steve King, R-Iowa, released a statement claiming the death of 15-year-old Sergio Adrían Hernández Güereca, who was shot by a U.S. Border Patrol agent on June 7, could have been prevented had the contentious “border wall” been in place in El Paso. Güereca was part of a group that allegedly threw rocks at U.S. law enforcement across the concrete banks of the Rio Grande.
“When faced with a life threatening situation, this agent appears to have responded to lethal force with lethal force as authorized. But this incident could have been avoided if the Administration had lived up to its responsibility under the ‘Secure Fence Act’ to build fences on our border,” King said.
Not so fast, the TBC quipped back.
“While few expect elected officials in Washington to understand every nuance of border security, members of Congress, such as Mr. King, should research basic facts before issuing press releases revealing their lack of acquaintance with reality,” said TBC chairman Del Rio Mayor Efrain Valdez. “Beginning in the early 20th century, the U.S. government has financed the construction of border fences in El Paso. In 1925, a ‘hog tight, horse high, and boot-legger-proof’ barbed-wire fence was built in El Paso. Observation towers were added in 1937.”
The towers were subsequently removed, but the fence was reinforced in 1978 with what its manufacturer said was wire so sharp “anyone who tried to scale them might lose his fingers and toes.” Holes were cut into the fence within a week.
“In the past few years, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security has spent hundreds of millions of dollars constructing new and ‘improved’ fencing between El Paso and Juarez, obviously with the same ineffective results that have been evident for 85 years. Mr. King, we understand Iowa’s interest in border security," Valdez said. "We merely suggest you become familiar with the facts next time, before shooting off your mouth.”
http://www.texastribune.org/blogs/post/2010/jun/15/tribblog-border-coalition-iowa-rep-check-your-facts/
Friday, May 7, 2010
Texas group calls on senators to nix border fence expansion
May 7, 2010
by G.W. Shulz
More than two-dozen cities and counties in southern Texas joined by environmentalists and immigrant-rights organizations are calling on two lawmakers to end their push for additional fencing along the nation’s boundary with Mexico.
In a letter to Senate leaders May 6, the Texas Border Coalition and others argued that the approximately 650 miles of fencing already constructed in recent years has divided communities, negatively impacted the environment and cost taxpayers a fortune. They say that despite investing $2.6 billion so far, the barrier’s value in stopping the flow of illegal immigration and drug traffickers from Mexico hasn’t been studied.
The lack of such an analysis was confirmed this week by the Government Accountability Office, a watchdog arm of Congress, which concluded in a report that Customs and Border Protection “cannot account separately for the impact of tactical infrastructure,” i.e. border fencing.
Nonetheless, Republican senators Jim DeMint of South Carolina and David Vitter of Louisiana on Wednesday proposed expanding the fence in a legislative amendment attached to an unrelated bill that addresses Wall Street reform.
DeMint said in a statement May 5 that little more than 30 miles of the fencing so far is double-layered and his amendment would make that the case for a full 700 miles. Last year, the press release said, a similar amendment was approved in the Senate by a 54-44 vote, but “Democrat leaders gutted the amendment behind closed doors.”
“We’ve had rhetoric and promises for four years without results,” DeMint said. “It’s time we completed the fence and secured our borders to protect American citizens.”
The letter from opponents, however, disputes that the barrier is successful in deterring intruders:
"The amendment has nothing to do with the issue of financial reform and threatens to play politics with the important goals of the underlying legislation. … Existing border walls have separated communities and families, cut through significant cultural sites and historic lands, caused damaging floods and erosion, and fractured habitat and migration corridors vital to wildlife pushed to the brink of extinction. These impacts are even more pronounced in light of the inability of a fence to solve our broken immigration system. If Congress perceives that the purpose of border walls is to seal the border from illegal activity, then the program is, and will continue to be, a costly failure."
The Texas Border Coalition represents several cities and counties in the southern area of the Lone Star State and filed suit against the Bush Administration in 2008 to stop 70 miles of fencing planned for the Rio Grande Valley. They argued at the time that the Department of Homeland Security failed to consult with them about the fence’s environmental and commercial impacts and claimed that the fence arbitrarily ceased at the property lines of wealthier landowners. A judge tossed the coalition’s legal challenge last year.
Other lawmakers in recent weeks, meanwhile, have raised questions about whether a costly and troubled border surveillance program known as SBInet should be abandoned due to delays and cost overruns. At one time, the government proposed lining the entire southwestern border with cameras, sensors and wired command centers that could detect illegal border crossers. But after spending somewhere in the neighborhood of $800 million, the defense contractor hired to build SBInet, Boeing Co., will complete only about 50 miles for certain.
The Obama Administration announced earlier this year that it was re-directing $50 million in Recovery Act funds set aside for SBInet to other technologies. Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.), chairman of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, during an April hearing called SBInet “a classic example of a program that was grossly oversold.” He’s argued in support of fencing and said the alternative to SBInet may be to double and even triple-layer the barrier in some areas of the border.
http://www.centerforinvestigativereporting.org/blogpost/20100507texasgroupcallsonsenatorstonixborderfenceexpansion
Monday, November 30, 2009
After fence fight, border leaders get proactive with feds
November 27, 2009
by Gary Martin
WASHINGTON — After several years of fighting the U.S.-Mexico border fence, a coalition of Texas elected officials is working with the Obama administration on ways to improve border ports and facilitate trade while fighting drug smuggling.
The Texas Border Coalition's involvement with policymaking comes after a bitter tangle with the federal government over construction of the fence that Congress and the White House approved, but border business leaders and human rights groups opposed.
“We've got to work together,” said Chad Foster, Eagle Pass mayor and the coalition's chairman. “But that is where the wheels came off the cart — when there was legislation passed without any consultation.”
Coalition members are working with J.D. Salinas, the regional administrator for the U.S. General Services Administration and former Hidalgo County judge, on improvements to land ports of entry to enhance trade and bolster security.
It's not a new direction for the coalition, whose members first found strength in numbers more than a decade ago when they bonded to beat back legislative mandates from Austin and Washington.
The Texas Border Coalition was formed in 1998, with representatives from 10 border counties and 19 cities along the Rio Grande from Brownsville to El Paso, to lobby the state and federal governments for infrastructure improvements.
But that goal was derailed when the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks prompted Congress and the Bush administration to seek ways to shore up security along the Mexican border.
The coalition fought the resulting fence, but couldn't prevent its construction. Foster called it “false security for mid-America” that hindered legitimate trade and cultural ties between the two countries.
The coalition was also outspoken against a plan by Republican Gov. Rick Perry to put Texas Rangers along the border this year to protect property owners from Mexican smugglers and drug cartel violence.
The “Ranger Recon” plan, as it was dubbed, coincided with the challenge to Perry by Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison, R-Texas, for the GOP gubernatorial nomination. The coalition dismissed Perry's plan as electioneering, and told him so in a letter.
“While each of our communities has their own unique issues,” Foster wrote, “being overwhelmed by criminal elements from Mexico is not one of them.”
But the organization's biggest battle was the border fence.
The Secure Border Initiative was passed by Congress with overwhelming support. Hutchison and Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, voted for the bill, as well as Democratic Sen. Barack Obama of Illinois.
Now, 670 miles of fence is under contract to be built, with 110 miles of it in Texas. Some portions in Texas still face legal challenges.
“We were against the fence act, but where some of the fence was built makes sense,” said Jose “Pepe” Aranda, Maverick County judge.
But this month, the coalition backed Democrats in Washington who rejected an appropriations amendment by Sen. Jim DeMint, R-S.C., that would have provided funds for more pedestrian fencing.
Aranda said the real challenge on the border now is safety. He said working with federal and state leaders is the first step.
U.S. Customs officials and the Border Patrol are working with local elected leaders on the challenge of stopping drug trafficking.
Aranda said Operation Streamline, launched by the Bush administration to find and deport unauthorized immigrants with criminal backgrounds, is a successful federal program.
“We need to be realists and understand what we are up against on the border,” Aranda said. “Sending the Texas Rangers down to the border? That's not going to do anything.”
As the Texas Border Coalition looks toward goals for next year, efforts should be concentrated on Austin, he added.
“Bringing attention to the border at the federal level has been successful,” Aranda said. “Coming onto next year, we need a stronger focus on the state Legislature.”
http://www.mysanantonio.com/news/politics/75454467.html
Thursday, November 12, 2009
Texas group warns of weaknesses at land ports
November 12, 2009
by Christopher Sherman
McALLEN, Texas — The country's understaffed land ports of entry need massive investments in infrastructure, technology and personnel to avoid becoming the path of choice for human and drug smugglers, according to a report released Wednesday by a border advocacy group.
The Texas Border Coalition, a group representing border city mayors, county judges and economic development commissions, called for $6 billion to improve land ports of entry and 5,000 new customs officers during the next four years. The group said the money is needed to correct the imbalance between the security at ports of entry and the security covering the points between.
"We definitely have to redirect the way we've been thinking," said Monica Weisberg-Stewart, chairwoman of the coalition's Border Security and Immigration Committee. In addition to shoring up security at the ports of entry, the additional funding and staffing would also help with facilitating legitimate trade and travel, said Weisberg-Stewart, a McAllen business owner.
From 1993 to a projected 2010, the Border Patrol budget has grown from $400 million to an expected $3.5 billion while funding for customs inspectors increased from $1.6 billion to an anticipated $2.7 billion during the same period, according to the report.
Comparisons between the security situation in the two areas are difficult. The only hard numbers available are for apprehensions of illegal immigrants, leaving how much gets by beyond that to guessing. But the coalition argues that the funding discrepancy is making ports of entry more attractive targets for smuggling.
"In the present environment, the (drug) cartels are choosing to conduct their trade across the bridges and highways, through the ports of entry and are rejecting the risk of crossing the Rio Grande and open spaces between the ports of entry," the report said.
It echoed one of the recommendations from the Southwest Border Task Force, created by Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, which advised in September that the ports of entry were in serious need of improvement.
And last month, the president of the National Treasury Employees Union, which represents customs officers, testified before Congress that the federal Customs and Border Protection agency needed several thousand additional customs officers and agriculture inspectors.
A 2007 report by the Government Accountability Office noted that the agency's managers at land ports said understaffing contributed to "morale problems, fatigue, lack of backup support and safety issues when officers inspect travelers — increasing the potential that terrorists, inadmissible travelers and illicit goods could enter the country."
Representatives of Customs and Border Protection and the General Services Administration, which controls the majority of the land port facilities, were not immediately able to offer comment. Government offices were closed Wednesday for Veterans Day.
There are 42 land ports of entry on the southern and northern borders.
The Texas Border Coalition, which opposed the border fence built along 670 miles of the southern border, plans to formally present its report at a conference Friday in Laredo.
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5ifAyAKJeZz9FqhQzbFSkiLiES1-QD9BU0DG80
Thursday, October 8, 2009
Border fence funds pulled at request of lawmakers
October 8, 2009
by Gary Martin
WASHINGTON — A provision to build an additional 300 miles of pedestrian fence along the U.S.-Mexico border has been stripped out of a $42.8 billion spending bill for the Department of Homeland Security.
The provision by Sen. Jim DeMint, R-S.C., was removed at the behest of House members from Texas, Arizona and California who called the fencing a waste of taxpayer money and an ineffective way to secure the border.
“We need to invest and secure our border and our land ports without being tied down to an amendment that is out of touch with border needs,” said Rep. Henry Cuellar, D-Laredo, who spearheaded the effort to remove the provision DeMint tucked into a Senate spending bill earlier this year.
The provision, approved 54-44 in the Senate in July, was supported by both Republican and Democratic senators from Texas, California and Arizona. New Mexico's two Democratic senators opposed the additional pedestrian fence.
The House version of the bill did not contain the provision.
Cornyn's complaint
This week, the House and Senate negotiators writing the final bill chose not to include DeMint's provision, prompting a protest from Sen. John Cornyn.
“I'm very concerned with anything that sends a signal that we're not serious about continuing to provide security along our border,” said Cornyn, R-Texas, who supported the DeMint provision.
But the Texas Border Coalition, a collective of border mayors and county officials, applauded the move. They had urged Democratic leaders in the House to remove the provision from the bill, saying the money could be better used to upgrade busy ports of entry that routinely see traffic congestion and delays.
Eagle Pass Mayor Chad Foster, the Texas Border Coalition chairman, said the decision is the first time community leaders “have been able to defeat an effort in Congress to require fence construction.”
‘Virtual fence'
Congress authorized 700 miles of fence along the U.S.-Mexico border in the Secure Fence Initiative of 2006. The Homeland Security Department has 370 miles of pedestrian fence under contract, with the remainder to be secured by vehicle barriers, sensors and other high-technology equipment to create a “virtual fence.”
More than 630 miles of fence and barriers have been completed, according to a DHS spokesman. Some portions of the uncompleted pedestrian fence in Texas are under court challenge.
The DeMint provision would have required that all 700 miles of barriers authorized by Congress in 2006 to be pedestrian fence, eliminating vehicle barriers and virtual fences. It called for the pedestrian fence to be completed by Dec. 31, 2010.
DeMint argued that the government had dragged its feet on securing the Southwest border.
Criticized as wasteful
Border lawmakers in the House called the DeMint provision wasteful after the Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress, found that costs to build a pedestrian fence had escalated to $7 million per mile.
“I say those dollars are better invested into supporting the manpower and resources at Customs and Border Patrol and local law enforcement,” Cuellar said.
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/metropolitan/6659413.html
Wednesday, September 9, 2009
Border mayors tell Congress fence won't work
September 9, 2009
by Gary Martin
WASHINGTON — A group of elected officials from Texas cities and counties along the U.S.-Mexico border urged Congress on Wednesday to strip a provision requiring the building of more border fencing from an annual spending bill.
The Texas Border Coalition wants a House-Senate conference committee to remove language from the spending bill for the Department of Homeland Security that would require the government to replace vehicle barriers and a high-technology “virtual fence” with pedestrian fencing.
Eagle Pass Mayor Chad Foster, the coalition's chairman, said the current fence, at a cost of $3.5 billion, has only forced narcotics traffickers and smugglers of undocumented immigrants to develop counterstrategies to move contraband and people into the United States.
With the recent building of some pedestrian fence, Foster said narco-traffickers and smugglers are now shifting their focus to busy land ports.
“If Congress perceives the purpose of the border fence is to seal the border from illegal activity, then the program is and will continue to be a failure,” Foster said.
The pedestrian fence provision was added as an amendment to the spending bill on a 54-44 vote in the Senate.
Republican Sens. Kay Bailey Hutchison and John Cornyn of Texas, and Democratic Sens. Dianne Feinstein and Barbara Boxer of California voted in favor of the amendment.
New Mexico Sens. Jeff Bingaman and Tom Udall, both Democrats, voted against the measure sponsored by Sen. Jim DeMint, R-S.C. Arizona Sens. Jon Kyl and John McCain, both Republicans, voted for it.
The House did not include the measure in its version of the spending bill, which is now before a House-Senate conference committee to iron out differences in the two pieces of legislation.
DeMint vowed to work to keep the provision in the final bill.
But House Democrats from the four Southwest border states are lobbying leaders to strip the provision from the bill and use the funds to better equip overcrowded and understaffed ports of entry.
Rep. Henry Cuellar, D-Laredo, called the DeMint amendment “a waste of taxpayer's money.”
Congress authorized 700 miles of fence along the U.S.-Mexico border in the Secure Fence Initiative of 2006. Homeland Security has 370 miles of fence under contract, with the remainder to be secured by vehicle barriers, as well as technology and sensors.
Some portions of uncompleted fence remain under court challenge.
The DeMint provision would require that pedestrian fence account for all 700 miles of barriers authorized by Congress in 2006, and be completed by Dec. 31, 2010.
The Texas Border Coalition, made up of mayors, county judges and eco
nomic development officials, argue that the fence funds would be better spent on improvements to border ports to better inspect cargo and facilitate legal trade.
http://www.mysanantonio.com/news/58155687.html
Thursday, June 11, 2009
Texans ask Obama to halt border fence
June 11, 2009
McALLEN, Texas — South Texas mayors, county judges and state legislators want President Barack Obama to stop construction of the Mexican border fence until a full review of border security policy is complete.
The Texas Border Coalition sent a letter dated June 9 appealing to Obama as the "last hope."
The Department of Homeland Security has completed about 630 miles of a planned 670 miles of barriers along the U.S.-Mexico border.
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/ap/tx/6471578.html#Wednesday, May 20, 2009
'Los Ebanos thanks you for the new rope,' Foster tells Senate panel
May 20, 2009
McALLEN, May 20 - Speaking at a Senate hearing in Washington on Wednesday, Eagle Pass Mayor and Texas Border Coalition Chair Chad Foster decried the lack of federal infrastructure dollars for major inland ports in Texas. Foster noted that the tiny hand-drawn ferry operation at Los Ebanos in western Hidalgo County got additional funding from the General Services Administration this year but bigger ports like Brownsville, Laredo and El Paso did not. “Los Ebanos thanks you for the new rope, but we need another $700 million, this time in the right account please,” Foster said. Foster was testifying before the Senate Committee on the Judiciary Subcommittee on Immigration, Refugees and Border Security. He again criticized the border wall plan. “In their headlong rush to achieve an arbitrary deadline to erect an ineffective wall, the Bush Administration chose to abandon our nation’s laws and commit us to preserving our environment, our culture, our history and our religious liberties. We can’t afford to go down that path – a path that waives all laws – again,” Foster said. Foster said the TBC supports repeal of unconstitutional waiver authority and the Secure Fence Act in favor of measures that will provide the border region with “real security.” The title of the hearing was “Securing the borders and America's points of entry, what remains to be done?” The Guardian has posted Foster’s prepared remarks below. Also testifying was Sam Vale, a founding member of the Border Trade Alliance (BTA), owner of Telemundo Channel 40 in the Rio Grande Valley and owner-operator of the Starr Camargo International Bridge. “The movement of goods and people at our borders generates 2 billion dollars a day in economic activity,” the BTA said, in a statement issued ahead of the hearing. “In order to better ensure our economic and physical security, BTA will testify that the federal government must do more to address the decades old backlog in our immigration codes, while providing more adequate annual infrastructure and resource investments at U.S. land ports of entry.” The BTA said that currently, a majority of U.S. land ports are “overburdened by the combination of vast federal security operations with massive increases in cross-border trade and travel volumes at U.S. border crossings.” The group said President Obama's plans to successfully achieve comprehensive immigration reform “hinge on the government's ability to improve the secure and efficient facilitation of legitimate trade and travel at our nation’s borders.” Others slated to testify were John Torres, deputy assistant secretary for operations, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, David V. Aguilar, chief, Office of Border Patrol, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, Thomas Winkowski, assistant commissioner, Office of Field Operations, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, J.D. Hayworth, former United States Representative of Arizona, Richard Wiles, sheriff, El Paso County, Texas, and Dr. Douglas Massey, professor of sociology and public affairs, Princeton University. Here are Foster’s prepared remarks: “Chairman Schumer, Ranking Member Cornyn and subcommittee members, I am Chad Foster, mayor of Eagle Pass, Texas, and chairman of the Texas Border Coalition. I am speaking today on behalf of 2.1 million Americans in 17 border counties of the 1,250-mile Texas-Mexico border. “Ours is a region of contrasts, exhibiting differences and similarities of language, culture, tradition, and economy. The multi-national, multi-cultural nature of our communities on both sides of the international boundary gives our region a distinct sense of place. “Our blending of cultures is unique. The Texas-Mexico border played a central role in shaping the history of our continent. Two civil wars occurred simultaneously where we live, and created such cross-cultural alliances and enmities that we could spend days rediscovering them. You can breathe easy, Mr. Chairman, because I won’t go that far back in time. “I only want to travel back two years to June 2007, when the Senate last debated immigration reform. I recall the opponents of the bill saying that the borders had to be secured before any visas could be reformed or any effort made to legalize the status of the undocumented among us or to institute a guest worker program. Those conditions included, now completed, just two years later: • 20,000-person Border Patrol force; “In my opinion, land ports are now our nation’s weakest link. We need your help and we would appreciate it now. “We are within sight of operational control of the border between the ports of entry, and that puts our ports under greater stress. According to the Government Accountability Office, we needed 4,000 new officers to secure the ports of entry before we placed the new emphasis on southbound checks to stop the trafficking of guns and cash. We needed $4 billion in infrastructure and technology – and I want to thank you for putting $700 million into the stimulus bill toward this goal – but you put most of the money in the wrong account. We need the money for CBP ports. We have three of those in Texas; two are on top of dams and one is a three-car hand ferry. Los Ebanos thanks you for the new rope, but we need another $700 million, this time in the right account please. “Mr. Chairman, our shared goal is security, and we need your help to fund these priorities that are ignored by the president’s budget. We need 1,600 more CBP officers, along with 400 canine units. We need the southbound operation to be controlled by the CBP, which has training in dealing with the traveling public, and not the Border Patrol, whose training with travelers is more confrontational. “We need $130 million for 350 new ICE investigators to work on firearm trafficking and money laundering investigations and $20 million for improved tactical field communications for CBP and ICE. We cannot afford to delay the $20 million CBP needs to modernize its database used to identify potential criminals at the ports of entry or the $50 million for Operation Stonegarden to reimburse state and local law enforcement for their participation in border actions. “The 9-11 terrorists entered the United States through ports of entry. Most undocumented aliens enter the United States through ports of entry. Most of the illegal drugs entering the United States come through ports of entry. No border wall will solve those problems. “Illegal border crossing arrests at the Texas-Mexico border have been falling for more than three years, without a wall, a great tribute to the deterrence of our Border Patrol and CBP officers. Arrests this year along the southern border are likely to be way below half the nearly 1.6 million during the peak of 2000. “In their headlong rush to achieve an arbitrary deadline to erect an ineffective wall, the Bush Administration chose to abandon our nation’s laws and commit us to preserving our environment, our culture, our history and our religious liberties. We can’t afford to go down that path – a path that waives all laws – again. “The Chertoff waivers will affect the natural movement of animal species, including the larger mammals that are on the threatened or endangered species lists, and cause irreparable harm to the unique eco- and bio-systems located along the Rio Grande River. They provided carte blanche for the destruction of cultural and religious artifacts that are irreplaceable to our heritage. “The avoidance and mitigation of these damages is not an inconvenience to the government. They are essential elements of our national fabric, guaranteed to the people of the United States under Articles I and II of the Constitution. We demand that Congress require the enforcement of our commitment to being a nation of laws. We support repeal of the unconstitutional waiver authority and urge the repeal of the Secure Fence Act in favor of measures that will provide our region with real security. “The Texas Border Coalition wants to finish the job of securing the border by enacting immigration reform. We support an earned legalization program for the undocumented people who are in the U.S. today. We need an effective guest worker program to prevent the immigration policy and political failures from repeating themselves in another general. We need more than a bill that balances the ideological and political continuums in Congress and the nation. We need policies that balance supply and demand, that provide circularity and stability in demographic and economic change for our hemisphere and that will guarantee our economic and national security for years to come.”
• DoD and DHS coordination plans;
• 600-plus miles of border fence, roads and vehicle barriers to achieve operational control;
• deployment of unmanned aerial vehicles and related surveillance technologies;
• cooperation among U.S., Canada, Mexico and Central American governments to improve security south of our border, specifically relating to gang and drug activity, and other law enforcement assistance;
• law enforcement relief for states and localities that provide border related assistance;
• more ICE agents and detention space;
• tightened voluntary departure requirements and expanded expedited removal procedures;
• improvements and additions to our ports of entry;
Monday, May 18, 2009
Federal judge dismisses US-Mexico border fence challenge
May 18, 2009
by Andrew Morgan
[JURIST] A federal judge on Friday dismissed [opinion, PDF] a lawsuit against the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) [official website] that sought to block construction of a fence along the US-Mexico border. The Texas Border Coalition [advocacy website], a group of Texan officials and business owners, filed suit [JURIST report] last year challenging the condemnation of land for the construction of the fence and the compensation paid to landowners for access to conduct surveys under the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 [text], the Administrative Procedure Act [text, PDF], and the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment [text]. Judge Reggie Walton of the US District Court for the District of Columbia [official website] found that the Coalition did not have standing to bring the suit because it was "unclear from the complaint whether any of the property owned by the plaintiff's members will actually be condemned," saying that:
It would make little procedural sense, and, indeed, thwart congressional will, to allow the plaintiff's members to preemptively challenge an anticipated condemnation when the Department's decision to pursue this course has not yet been rendered.Walton also granted the government's motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6) [text] because there was insufficient legal basis for the injunctive relief sought by the Coalition.
The 700-mile US-Mexico border fence [JURIST news archive] was authorized [JURIST report] in 2006 by President George W. Bush [official profile]. Former DHS secretary Michael Chertoff [official profile] used controversial legal waivers, authorized under Title I sec. 102 of the Real ID Act [text, PDF; JURIST news archive], to circumvent local and environmental laws which had slowed construction of the fence, including an October 2007 waiver overriding a federal district court ruling that halted construction [JURIST report] on environmental grounds. In September, US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) [official website] officials told Congress [hearing materials] that legal challenges and technological problems led to cost increases and delays in fence construction.
http://jurist.law.pitt.edu/paperchase/2009/05/federal-judge-dismisses-us-mexico.php
Saturday, May 16, 2009
Judge throws out border fence case
Associated Press
by Nedra Pickler
WASHINGTON (AP) — A federal judge has thrown out a lawsuit to stop construction of the U.S.-Mexico border fence ordered by the Bush administration.
The Texas Border Coalition, a coalition of mayors and business and community leaders, sued the Homeland Security Department last year. The group said the department did not fairly negotiate compensation with landowners for access to their land for six-month surveys to choose fence sites.
The Bush administration pledged to build roughly 660 miles of fencing and other barriers along the border to help keep out illegal immigrants. About 625 miles is complete.
But U.S. District Judge Reggie B. Walton ruled Friday that the coalition did not have standing to sue since its members were not the affected property owners.
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jVdixxxUKMR4V7LXmPSdHppIur5QD986VGVO0Tuesday, April 14, 2009
TBC: Border wall and the Obama promise
April 11, 2009
McALLEN, April 11 - In a 3,000-plus word memorandum sent to Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, the Texas Border Coalition discusses in-depth the border wall issue. The memo was written for TBC by its immigration committee Chair Monica Weisberg Stewart. She delivered the memo to Napolitano in Laredo on April 3. Here is the section of the memo dealing with the border wall: “During President Obama’s campaign, he stated that he would "reverse that policy" of building a wall, “that the key is to consult with local communities,” adding that the Bush Administration did not do such a good job of consulting. He said, “Having the border patrolled, surveillance, deploying effective technology, that's going to be the better approach.” In Berlin, he noted, "The walls between the countries with the most and those with the least cannot stand. These now are the walls we must tear down." “We are therefore surprised that the Obama Administration has proceeded with new construction of fencing in Cameron and Hidalgo Counties without consulting with local communities and that the person responsible for consultation in the Bush Administration (who didn’t do such a good job, according to President Obama) is still in charge in the Obama Administration. “Like President Obama, the Texas Border Coalition supports smart and effective measures that will achieve true border security. We have suggested fencing alternatives in Texas, such as the Vega Project in Laredo, the Eagle Pass Park project, the Brownsville Weir and Reservoir project, and the clearing of the banks of the Rio Grande – north and south – of vegetation such as Carrizo cane and salt cedar that provide hiding places for illegal border-crossers and put our Border Patrol agents at risk. “We support physical barriers in areas where they make sense and are agreed to by elected county and municipal officials, such as in Del Rio and Hidalgo County. We support smarter, more effective solutions where fences won’t work including radar, cameras, sensors and more effective deployment of Border Patrol agents. “In most places, the border fence won’t work, a fact that former Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff admits to, acknowledging that illegal crossers will go around, over, through and under it. Border Patrol officials liken it more to a “speed bump” since it is only intended to slow down the immigrants by three to four minutes. The fence is more gap than barrier: the fence covers less than 370 of the 1,969 miles of U.S.-Mexican border, less than 1 mile in 5. “Arizona landowner Bill Odle has begun collecting ladders used by crossers near his home. His neighbor Glenn Spencer says people on the Mexican side can get on the roof of a pickup truck, climb a few feet over the fence, drop down onto the posts on the U.S. side and then jump down to the ground. Border crossers in New Mexico abandon plasma torches after they cut through the fence. Border Patrol has discovered more than 30 tunnels under the fence. Around, over, through and under: it won’t work. “We have doubts about the Border Patrol’s claim that the fence is the only way to achieve persistent impedance. When any alternative form of impedance was proposed to the CBP or Corps of Engineers during the now moot environmental assessment period, officials made clear theirs was the only alternative that was going to be considered. This is despite greater consistent impedance provided by alternatives such as the Brownsville Weir. “At a time when our national government is projected to spend nearly $2 trillion more than it has in revenue in the current fiscal year, there is no possible excuse for wasting $50 billion on a program that we know -- and even its strongest advocates admit -- will fail to accomplish its mission and that there are more effective, less costly alternatives that the prior Administration refused to even consider. “In Texas, the fence is being built more than a mile from the border, trapping people – workers, families, farmers, ranchers, retirees – and wildlife in a “dead zone” that is north of the Rio Grande, but south of the fence. That means that when fires, floods, medical crises or crime require evacuation, emergency or law enforcement, emergency personnel won’t be able to rescue people or property. It also means that when drug cartels decide it is in their interest to occupy dead zone property, local law enforcement will be prevented from defending their territory. “Wildlife won’t be able to access the life-giving resources of the Rio Grande. People and wildlife – in many cases, endangered species – will die. Additionally, wildlife sanctuaries that have been a popular attraction for local schools will no longer be a safe place to visit, as school districts are refusing to travel south of the fence for liability purposes. Being the only southern border state that is separated from Mexico by a river, the Texas border requires a unique solution because one-size-does-not-fit-all. “It is an ineffective solution that isolates only one part of the problem and that will likely make the other parts of the security whole – such as the lack of resources to make security through Ports of Entry appropriately effective – worse. “This project will endanger public safety, reduce income and economic activity, destroy cultural and community resources, erode water resources, endanger wildlife and lead to additional negative consequences that we are not yet able to forecast.”
Thursday, February 12, 2009
City sits on border fence
Brownsville Herald
Emma Perez-Trevino
The City Commission tabled action Thursday on an agreement regarding the construction of a border fence with the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, announcing that the proposal would be re-evaluated by the federal government.
Just minutes before the start of the scheduled public hearing, Commissioner Anthony Troiani said that new DHS Secretary Janet Napolitano's staff indicated that the proposal would be re-evaluated.
"We are in a position to re-evaluate the situation," Troiani said at the onset of the session that drew a standing room only crowd in commission chambers at City Hall.
Troiani said that Napolitano's staff had not been aware that the federal negotiating team had given the city an ultimatum or a deadline for approval of the agreement and had not known of Thursday's meeting in Brownsville.
Commissioner Ricardo Longoria said that city officials hope to meet with Napolitano later this month or in mid-March.
Troiani pointed to the efforts of commissioners, city staff and U.S. Rep. Solomon P. Ortiz, D-Corpus Christi, while Mayor Pat M. Ahumada Jr. said, "This didn't just happen." Instead, the mayor pointed to the efforts of the Texas Border Coalition and No Border Wall groups.
Discussions between the mayor and commissioners were contentious as usual, with commissioners noting that they are not the ones who are divided.
Ahumada, on the other hand, felt that Commissioner Charlie Atkinson should not have taken part in the deliberations due to a potential conflict of interest because Atkinson is a federal officer.
Some commissioners also told Ahumada that they fear going to Mexico because he has said in Mexico that commissioners are in favor of the border wall.
Residents urged the mayor and commissioners to put differences aside, encouraging communication and unity.
"We need you all to unite," Erasmo Castro said. "We need something that is substantial, something that is clear, that is transparent. We need to be informed. That is all we ask," Castro added.
Jay Johnson-Castro, who has protested the wall for years throughout the border and has walked more than 700 miles in protest, urged the commission to put their political differences aside.
"Join with ‘We the people' and say no to this," Johnson-Castro emphasized. "Don't be divided on this. Stand with us. This is ground zero in Texas," he said, telling commissioners and the mayor to be statesmen and not politicians.
Judy Vera with Valley Interfaith also pointed out to The Brownsville Herald that the organization obtained many signatures opposing the border wall, which have been presented to the commission. "We really touched a lot of people," Vera said.
Dennis Sanchez, who represents two landowners near the city's property between the Gateway International Bridge and the B&M International Bridge, told the commission that neither the federal government nor the city consulted with his clients.
"Now is the opportunity," Sanchez said, noting that it is great news that the city will actually have the opportunity to meet with federal officials in Washington, D.C. He also told the commission that it needs to be united.
Sanchez said: "Look at this as a business deal and try to make the best deal you can."
http://www.brownsvilleherald.com/news/napolitano_94768___article.html/city_staff.htmlWednesday, January 21, 2009
Opponents of the Border Fence Look to Obama
January 21, 2009
Federal bureaucrats call it the "border fence." The residents along the Texas-Mexico border say it's a wall echoing the Cold War. And south of the Rio Grande, Governor Humberto Moreira of the Mexican state of Coahuila has dubbed it a "wall of hate." But no matter what the controversial barrier being constructed between Mexico and the U.S. is called, the $1.6 billion, 670-mile-long first phase is close to completion as President Barack Obama enters office.
And for Obama, who voted for the border-fence bill back in 2006, the barrier may be best described as a big potential headache. Opponents are already appealing to him to halt construction and re-evaluate the project. But so far, the new Administration has given no indication that it is seriously considering doing so. While it has said it will make comprehensive immigration reform a priority, a spokesperson told TIME that Obama supports the fence "as long as it is one part of a larger strategy on border security that includes more boots on the ground and increased use of technology."
This, despite repeated pleas from border Democratic officeholders, residents with family and business ties on both sides of the river, and conservationists who fear their 30-year effort to string parcels of land into a necklace of treasured preserves for native fauna and flora will be destroyed as the acreage ends up in a riverside no-man's-land. On Wednesday, Obama's first day in office, advocates of immigration reform are holding a rally in Washington in which a multisectarian group of religious leaders will give the Immigration and Customs Enforcement Building a ritualistic cleansing to highlight the call to end workplace immigration raids and the construction of the border fence. (See pictures of the fence between the U.S. and Mexico.)
A map on the home page of the U.S. Customs and Border Protection website shows the daily progress of the border-fence construction — green for completed, yellow for under construction and red for planned. There is a line of green and yellow for the 693-mile border between Mexico and the states of California, Arizona and New Mexico. The colors turn to red on the far western and eastern edges of the 1,241-mile Mexico-Texas border. In between, there are just small patches of red, since only 110 miles of Texas border fence are planned in the initial stage.
But those 110 miles have proved the most problematic for the Department of Homeland Security, the agency charged with overseeing the project. While much of the U.S. land on the border west of Texas is held by the Federal Government or large landowners, the projects planned for Texas involve negotiating with a hodgepodge of cities, private landowners, tribal lands, farmers and conservationists.
"It's a sorry piece of work," says Mayor Chad Foster of Eagle Pass, Texas. Foster chairs the Texas Border Coalition, a group of cities, landowners, nonprofit conservation groups and Native American tribal communities that has sued the Federal Government to block construction in some areas. Plans in Eagle Pass, some 500 miles east of El Paso, call for the wall — now about 30% complete — to cross a municipal golf course. Initially, the city welcomed the idea of stadium lights on the bluff overlooking the city and the construction of a decorative fence, but when the plans were revealed, the wall-like barrier prompted community opposition. "One size doesn't fit all," insists Foster, whose community of some 50,000 people has close business ties to neighboring Piedras Negras, a city three times the size of its U.S. neighbor. He has pressed for a variety of alternative approaches, including the use of sensors to detect illegal movement and the eradication of "Carrizo cane" — an invasive, nonnative, tall river weed that provides easy hiding places along the riverbanks.
Meanwhile, south of the river, Moreira is planning a "green wall" of 400,000 tress along a 217-mile stretch of the border as a symbol of Mexico's protest. The green wall will provide sanctuary for the deer and other animals that normally cross to and fro between the two countries, Foster says. A confirmed supporter of President Bush, Foster believes that Bush, as governor, shared a widely held view in the region that Texas has a symbiotic relationship with Mexico. "I feel let down. I see the President as a fixer," Foster says. He believes "weighty issues" like Iraq distracted Bush, while national media voices like Fox News' Bill O'Reilly and CNN's Lou Dobbs have fanned national sentiment on the border fence. "I am optimistic that with border governors like Governor [Janet] Napolitano, Obama is getting people in the Cabinet who understand the border," Foster says. (See who's who in Barack Obama's White House.)
But for Texas conservationists, any shift may come too late, according to Laura Huffman, state director of the Texas Nature Conservancy. In the last week of 2008, the Department of Homeland Security sued the conservancy in a condemnation proceeding involving the Lennox Southmost Preserve, a 1,000-acre parcel that is just that — southmost — where the Rio Grande meets the Gulf of Mexico near Brownsville, Texas. The preserve, bought in 1999 by the conservancy for $2.5 million, is home to a rare grove of native sabal palms through which endangered ocelots and rare jaguarundi roam.
The Federal Government has condemned a narrow strip of land about 60 ft. wide and 6,000 ft. long running across the preserve and has offered to compensate the nonprofit with a $114,000 payment. The fence will effectively place 800 acres of the peninsula south of the wall, including equipment sheds, management offices and the preserve's on-site warden's home. Several small, organic farm plots leased to locals will also be in the no-man's-land. A similar fate is facing an adjoining sabal plam preserve owned by the Audubon Society. Huffman fears that the endangered palms, prized as garden totems, will be susceptible to poachers.
The preserve is just one of several linked along the river that attract visitors from all around the world, particularly bird watchers — last April, the sighting of a rare South American fork-tailed flycatcher, not seen in the area since 1879, attracted more than 2,000 visitors. "What's sad is, this threatens the effort, the partnership — public, private and nonprofits — that has worked together in this area," Huffman says. The wall may shatter a three-year, $100 million effort to restore habitats and preserve vital native species, she says.
The conservancy plans to pursue all legal remedies, including joining this month's appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court by the border coalition group to strike down Homeland Security's waiver of 32 federal, state, local and tribal environmental rules in order to construct the fence — a power granted by Congress when the agency was established in the aftermath of 9/11. The department does not comment on the 300-plus lawsuits making their way through the courts. In visits to the region, Homeland Security Chairman Michael Chertoff has said the numerous lawsuits have slowed progress, but 90% to 95% of the initial 670 miles will either be completed or have had ground broken as Bush leaves office.
As for opponents in Brownsville, on the eastern end of the Texas-Mexico border, they plan a symbolic retirement party for Chertoff this week complete with piñatas and mariachi music.
Even an 11th-hour announcement by the Bush Administration promising $50 million in mitigation projects to address environmental and cultural issues in sensitive areas, including tribal lands, has not impressed opponents and is likely to be reviewed by the incoming Administration.
"The wall will surely hurt American interests all across the Americas for a whole generation," wrote State Representative Elliott Shapleigh, a Democrat and a fifth-generation El Pasoan, in a recent Op-Ed. "Is it too much too soon to ask that this wall come down or is it the right thing to do at the right time in history? If not now, when? If not under President-elect Barack Obama, then who?"
Watch a video of Texans fighting the border fence.
http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1872650,00.html
Thursday, November 13, 2008
Texas Border Coalition leaders testify against border wall in Austin today
November 13, 2008
AUSTIN, November 19 - Five leading members of the Texas Border Coalition will testify against the federal government’s border wall plan at a hearing hosted by the Mexican American Legislative Caucus at the state Capitol today.
The five are Eagle Pass Mayor Chad Foster, who chairs the TBC, Brownsville Mayor Pat Ahumada, Laredo Mayor Raul Salinas, El Paso County Attorney José Rodríguez, and Texas Produce Association President and CEO John McClung.
The Guardian has the submitted written testimony of all five in its Border Life section.
Click here to read the testimony submitted by Foster.
Click here to read the testimony submitted by Salinas.
Click here to read the testimony submitted by Rodríguez.
Click here to read the testimony submitted by McClung.
Click here to read the testimony submitted by Ahumada.
The MALC hearing is being chaired by state Rep. Eddie Lucio, D-San Benito, a member of the non-partisan group. Lucio said the hearing will allow Texas House members to gain an insight on the impact a border wall will have on the economy, environment, and private property rights of Texans living along the border.
“The Texas border with Mexico thrives due to its close relationship with its neighbor to the South; it is imperative that we understand how a border wall would affect Texas’ relationship with Mexico,” Lucio said.
Lucio took members of Congress on a tour of parts of Brownsville last April to show where the border wall might be built. It included parts of the historic Fort Brown complex. Since then, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has reached an agreement with the University of Brownsville to limit the amount of fencing that will be built.
Opponents of the border wall, including South Texas congressmen, are hoping that the incoming Obama administration will halt construction of the border wall and put more emphasis on cameras, sensors and extra Border Patrol agents as a means of securing the border. Last week, U.S. Rep. Henry Cuellar announced that DHS had halted plans to build movable border fencing in Roma, Rio Grande City, and Los Ebanos.
Lucio said the border wall directly impacts South Texas communities. Raising awareness of how federal legislation affects Texan constituents is essential to ensuring that local rights and concerns are not overlooked at the national level, he said, arguing that the federal government needs to take account of local and state viewpoints when implementing policy that affects border communities.
Rep. Pete Gallego, D-Alpine, is the chair of MALC. He agreed with Lucio’s analysis. “Every community on the Rio Grande is unique, a border wall may not address the varying concerns along the Texas border,” Gallego said.
The TBC has been a vocal critic of the border wall plan. Just this week, the group slammed U.S. Customs and Border Protection for blocking the input Valley landowners could have made in federally-required talks over the border wall.
The TBC also condemned a CBP decision to continue land acquisition near Roma, Rio Grande City and Los Ebanos even after the agency announced it would indefinitely halt construction of movable fencing.
“TBC is dumbfounded by CBP’s continued resistance to consultation with local landowners and the community, and by CBP’s unjustifiable demands for secrecy,” Foster said.
“Equally disturbing, CBP is continuing to pursue legal action to condemn the land of the people in Roma, Rio Grande City and Los Ebanos for a fence that the International Boundary & Water Commission won’t support,” Foster said.
Foster pointed out that TBC and DHS officials agreed in April to participate in a series of fence site tours in the Valley, known as “walk the line,” to help satisfy federal requirements outlined in the Consolidated Fiscal 2008 Appropriations Act.
Under the law, homeland security officials are obliged to consult with the Secretary of the Interior, the Secretary of Agriculture, states, local governments, Indian tribes, and property owners in communities where the wall is to be built. The point is to minimize the barrier’s impact on Rio Grande Valley communities and residents from an environmental, cultural and economic standpoint, Foster said.
TBC members had hoped the tour would take place before the congressionally imposed fence construction deadline of Dec. 31. But on Nov. 4, Foster said, CBP officials told TBC that attendance would be limited to coalition members only and that individual landowners or their attorneys would not be allowed to “walk the line.”
Rodríguez said he was looking forward to testifying at the MALC hearing about a federal lawsuit El Paso County and the City of El Paso filed this summer challenging Congress’ unconstitutional delegation of authority that allowed Secretary of Homeland Security Michael Chertoff to waive more than 30 federal, state, and local laws, in order to accelerate the construction of the border wall.
Rodríguez said a border wall will not keep immigrants out of the U.S. What it will do, he said, is bring serious environmental, economic and cultural consequences to the El Paso and Juarez region.
Rodríguez pointed to recent data from DHS which shows that this year, in the El Paso Sector, the number of undocumented immigrants apprehended by the Border Patrol dropped 60 percent in relation to the previous year. He pointed out that the drop in detentions was achieved before the construction of the border fence even began.
Rodríguez says the data refutes DHS’s contention that the border wall is necessary to maintain operational control of the border.
“A multi-billion dollar effort to construct the Border Wall simply does not make sense. At a time when America faces a severe financial crisis it is simply irresponsible to pour additional money into a wall that will scar our environmental landscape and damage our relationship with communities across the border,” Rodríguez said.
“Instead of deterring illegal immigration, the wall will symbolize not only a failed immigration policy, but also a country barricading itself from the rest of the world.
Rodríguez said he will explain to members of the Texas House of Representatives that the best way to tackle the problem of illegal immigration is to seek approval of comprehensive immigration reform.
http://www.riograndeguardian.com/rggnews_story.asp?story_no=22
Tuesday, November 11, 2008
‘Walk the Line’ leaves out property owners
November 10, 2008
A government-sponsored program that once promised to answer lingering questions about the border fence will now exclude individual property owners.
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security and the Texas Border Coalition, a group of elected officials and community leaders from the Texas border, began planning the series of on-the-ground consultations - dubbed Walk the Line - in April.
"We expect to get input from the people who live in these areas," Angela de Rocha, a DHS spokeswoman, told The Brownsville Herald in early October. "We're still planning community outreach even though we've begun awarding contracts."
But in a Nov. 4 letter to TBC, David Pagan, an advisor to the Customs and Border Protection commissioner, wrote that, "CBP cannot support including parties beyond immediate TBC members in the fence tours, with the possible exception of interested state and federal elected officials."
If the meeting was open to the public, Pagan wrote, consultations could devolve into a forum for local opposition to the fence. And pending land condemnation lawsuits would likely color the interactions between government officials and local landowners, restricting the breadth of consultations.
Many Valley landowners - who saw Walk the Line as their last chance to clarify key concerns about the project - are embittered by the government's change of heart.
Landowner Pamela Taylor is still unsure how she'll access her property once the 18-foot steel barrier is erected north of her home. It's a question she planned to ask the fence's planners during Walk the Line.
"It's a simple courtesy," Taylor said. "All we wanted was some honesty."
TBC officials are also disappointed by what they see as a betrayal of the program's original intentions.
"TBC is dumbfounded by CBP's continued resistance to consultation with local landowners and the community, and by CBP's unjustifiable demands for secrecy," Eagle Pass Mayor and TBC Chairman Chad Foster said.
In September, Congress approved DHS' $400 million appropriations request, allowing the government to continue work on the border fence after the project had exhausted its initial budget.
In his letter approving the request, Rep. David Price, D-N.C., chairman of the homeland security subcommittee, asked Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff to improve consultation and assessment in disputed border areas.
Initially, landowners like Taylor saw Walk the Line as a response to Price's suggestion - a chance to ask questions before the fence alters lives along the Rio Grande. Now, they're unsure where the answers will come from.
"We're so afraid we're going to be left vulnerable," Taylor said.
http://www.brownsvilleherald.com/news/border_91659___article.html/fence_tbc.html
Monday, October 27, 2008
Officials on border questioning need for fence
Houston Chronicle
October 26, 2008
For business and elected leaders in Texas border towns, it's a simple question: Since arrests of illegal immigrants are declining steadily along the Texas-Mexico border, why should the controversial and costly fence be completed?
An analysis by the Texas Border Coalition, an association of elected officials and business leaders, shows a 56 percent drop in arrests during the last four years by the U.S. Border Patrol on the Texas-Mexico border.
Government officials have maintained for years that fewer arrests mean fewer immigrants are trying to cross the border illegally.
The declining immigration arrests have revived the debate over the effectiveness of the planned fence because only a half-mile of the 110 miles of pedestrian fencing planned for the Texas border is finished. As government budget deficits soar, some question how fiscally prudent it is to build and maintain a project the Congressional Research Service estimates to cost $49 billion.
Eagle Pass Mayor Chad Foster, who heads the border coalition, said a steady increase of Border Patrol staffing is responsible for the declining arrests.
"We have a new Border Patrol station opened in Eagle Pass in the last six months, and the Border Patrol has continued to recruit agents," Foster said. "I think because of their strong presence (on the border), that links back to reduced apprehensions."
However, some experts maintain that a slowing economy is more responsible for the lower number of arrests. With fewer jobs available, fewer immigrants try to migrate north. That raises an obvious question: When the U.S. economy recovers, won't more immigrants try to cross into America illegally, thus making a case for a border fence?
Foster, however, said by the time the economy bounces back Congress will have passed long-anticipated immigration reform that includes a guest worker program. Immigrant workers will cross the border lawfully through ports of entry.
His border group notes that in San Diego, where heavy fencing and walls have been in place for years, apprehensions are up 28 percent during the last four years.
"Here we are in middle of a financial crisis, and we're going to spend billions on something that doesn't make sense?" said Laredo Mayor Raul Salinas. "Walls don't work — people go under, over and around them."
Fence widely opposed
Elected officials from nearly every Texas border town oppose the fence, saying it's not as effective as more border agents and installing high-tech surveillance technology.
A U.S. Customs and Border Protection spokesman said that by mid-October, 210 of the 370 miles of planned pedestrian fencing and 153 of the 300 miles of vehicle barriers were finished, most of it in New Mexico, Arizona and California.
"Our operational analysis of the border has shown that fencing is a critical component of our border security strategy," said CBP spokesman Michael Friel. "The Border Patrol has made the determination that fencing is needed in certain areas along our nation's border."
Friel said construction will pick up on the Texas border as the Dec. 31 deadline nears to complete all 670 miles of fencing mandated for the Southwest border.
He said it was "not logical" to suggest that areas with fencing have more border crossers.
According to Border Patrol statistics, apprehensions of illegal immigrants along the Southwest border have fallen dramatically in the last four years. In fiscal year 2005, nearly 1.2 million immigrants were arrested, dropping to 1 million in 2006 and 860,000 by 2007. In the first 11 months of the most recent fiscal year, which ended Sept. 30, arrests on the border had fallen to 660,000.
The head of a border agents union said fencing only delays illegal immigrants for the few minutes it takes them to climb over the barrier. If there are not enough agents in the area to detain them as they attempt to enter, they simply slip by.
"We don't build fences that slice and dice people," said T.J. Bonner, president of the 14,000-member National Border Patrol Council. "We design fences that slow people down ... and if you don't have the agents in place, that's all you've done."
Bonner said immigration arrests are misleading because agents say two illegal immigrants make it across the border for every one who is detained.
He said the higher number of arrests in San Diego is related to moving agents to Arizona.
"Tucson staffing has increased while the staffing in San Diego has decreased. That explains why (illegal immigrants are) going back to San Diego — because the odds of being caught in Tucson are higher," Bonner said.
Dual functions
Opposition to the fence has been blunted in some border communities, where the government incorporated the barrier with needed projects.
In Hidalgo County, county and drainage district officials teamed up with the federal government and are rebuilding dirt levees on the river with 22 miles of concrete walls topped with security fencing. The $179 million project, funded in part with $48.5 million in local flood control funds, is on existing right-of-way and does not require land acquisition.
In Laredo, plans to fence miles of riverfront were scrapped when local Border Patrol officials determined it was not needed. Instead, Border Patrol officials added hundreds of agents, are planning to clear thick stands of non-native cane that provides hiding places on the river bank and instituted a zero-tolerance arrest policy for first-time border crossers. As a result, arrests have dropped 23 percent in the last fiscal year.
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/metropolitan/6079516.html#
Friday, October 10, 2008
Texas reps want next president to think again on border fence
October 10, 2008
WASHINGTON — Texas congressmen, citing skyrocketing costs to build a fence along the U.S.-Mexico border, said Thursday they would push the next presidential administration for more cost-effective measures to control drug smuggling and illegal immigration.
U.S. Rep. Henry Cuellar, D-Laredo, and Rep. Michael McCaul, R-Austin, made the comments after a Rio Grande flyover to view efforts on the ground by U.S. Customs and Border Protection.
“Let's regroup and provide border security in a smart way and not just waste the taxpayers' dollars,” Cuellar said.
McCaul called for more state and local funding to bolster law enforcement efforts, saying, “What spills across our border is a problem for every community in Texas.”
A report released by the Government Accountability Office just before Congress adjourned in September said the cost of building pedestrian fencing has shot up to $7 million per mile from estimates of $4 million per mile in February.
Ralph Basham, the CBP commissioner, has said the cost overruns are the result of rising prices for steel, materials and fuel.
Cuellar said the increased cost should prompt a serious review by the next Congress and the incoming administration.
Local officials agree.
Eagle Pass Mayor Chad Foster, chairman of the Texas Border Coalition, said he wants comprehensive immigration reform, not just fencing, to stop unauthorized immigrants.
“We look forward to working with the new administration, whoever it may be, to provide real solutions that will finish the job of securing our borders and reforming a broken immigration system,” Foster said.
A goal to build 670 miles of fence this year under the Secure Border Initiative, undertaken by the Department Homeland Security, cannot be met, officials concede.
Lawsuits have contributed to the delays, particularly in Texas, where cities and citizens along the U.S. side of the border object to the fence construction, according to the GAO, the investigative arm of Congress.
Of the 122 border landowners who have refused to sell their U.S. property to the government for fence construction, 97 are located in the Rio Grande Valley, a GAO report said.
In addition, 20 of the Rio Grande Valley landowners are defendants in lawsuits filed by the federal government, on advice of Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff, for condemnation or taking of property, according to the GAO.
Richard Stana, GAO director for homeland security issues, said in the report, “Costs are increasing, the life-cycle cost is not yet known, and land acquisition issues pose challenges to DHS in meeting the goal it set.”
Of the 670 miles of border fencing planned, 109.5 miles are located in Texas. A short stretch of fence near El Paso is completed, and other sections are under construction in Hudspeth County and Eagle Pass.
To date, fencing costs in Texas have reached $575.6 million, said DHS spokeswoman Angela de Rocha.
Rep. Silvestre Reyes, D-El Paso; Rep. Ciro Rodriguez, D-San Antonio; Rep. Ruben Hinojosa, D-Mercedes; and Rep. Solomon Ortiz, D-Corpus Christi, have also urged a complete review of fence construction.
http://www.mysanantonio.com/news/state/30728139.html
Tuesday, October 7, 2008
‘Walk the line’: Valley residents will have the opportunity to see where fence will be built
October 6, 2008
For more than a year, South Texas residents have complained about the federal government's lack of transparency in its efforts to construction the border fence.
A lack of consultation, residents say, has bred confusion in border communities like Brownsville, where landowners are still waiting to hear how the barrier will affect their property.
But a new program sponsored by both the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and Texas Border Coalition - unlikely bedfellows after a year of fence-related friction - could answer lingering questions about the future of border security in South Texas.
The program, informally called "Walk the Line," will give residents the opportunity to inspect the predicted footprint of the border fence with some of the barrier's architects.
"We expect to get input from the people who live in these areas," said Angela de Rocha, a DHS spokeswoman. "We're still planning community outreach even though we've begun awarding contracts."
The tours, which will be offered in late October or early November, are expected to span much of the southwest border.
"Community leaders will be able to physically see where the fence will be built... and gain the knowledge they've been seeking for nearly a year," said Billy Moore, a TBC consultant.
DHS held a series of town hall meetings on the fence last fall, but many criticized the meetings, alleging that there was no room for constructive dialogue. TBC Chairman Chad Foster was one of the leading critics of the government's open houses, which he called little more than "meals in restaurants and phone calls."
When the project ran out of money in September, U.S. Rep David Price, D-NC, the chairman of the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Homeland Security, approved an additional $378 million dollars for fence construction, but stipulated that consultation between the government and border communities should continue.
In September, Price suggested that DHS "revisit border areas that remain in dispute with local communities... and seek to improve the hands-on consultation process."
For many Cameron County residents, "Walk the Line" could be a last opportunity to ask questions and offer feedback before construction begins.
"They want to know where there are going to be gates," TBC's Moore said. "Our goal is to provide them with these kinds of critical answers."
http://www.brownsvilleherald.com/news/border_90590___article.html/fence_residents.html
Monday, September 22, 2008
Congress approves additional border fence funding
September 22, 2008
By Kevin Sieff
Members of Congress will not stand in the way of the border fence's construction, despite the project's rising costs.
The Homeland Security Appropriations Subcommittee approved a reprogramming request worth nearly $400 million, allowing construction of the barrier to continue in South Texas. Rising costs of raw materials exhausted funding allocated for the project.
"This committee will not stand in the way of (the U.S. Department of Homeland Security's) efforts to construct fencing by the end of the year solely because of funding shortfalls, even though I have serious doubt about its ability to accomplish its stated goals," wrote Subcommittee Chairman David Price, D-NC, in a letter to DHS Secretary Michael Chertoff.
Price, who voted against the border fence in 2006, expressed his concern about the barrier's construction, urging DHS to "walk the line" in Cameron and Hidalgo counties, and to limit the duration of contracts to February 2009. But the appropriations request was approved with few concrete stipulations.
The money will be redirected from a number of DHS accounts, including $214 million from planned technology investments and $35 million from U.S. Border Patrol. Technology improvements on the border will now be shifted into 2009 or 2010, Price said.
Congress' decision was greeted with derision from the barrier's opponents.
"The Texas Border Coalition (TBC) is disappointed that Congress has approved the reprogramming of $400 million in fiscal 2008 funding to cover the cost overruns for the border wall," said TBC Chairman Chad Foster. "TBC is convinced that the border wall is a waste of taxpayer funds - it won't work, it is lethal to people and wildlife and eventually will be torn down."
With its funding problems resolved, the federal government must now settle more than 200 pending lawsuits before the fence can be constructed in parts of South Texas, including Cameron County. Only 341 miles of the proposed 670 miles of new fencing have been constructed to date.
In response to recent legal and financial holdups, DHS now states that the barrier will be under contract, rather than completed, by the end of 2008.
http://www.themonitor.com/articles/funding_17622___article.html/additional_approves.html
Wednesday, September 10, 2008
Congress should not provide more money for fence, Texas border officials say
September 10, 2008
AUSTIN - Congress should reject the Bush administration's request for another $400 million to build fencing on the U.S.-Mexico border, a coalition of Texas border officials and business leaders said Wednesday.
"It would be a taxpayer travesty for Congress to reward DHS for its inability to control spending," Eagle Pass Mayor Chad Foster, chairman of the Texas Border Coalition, wrote in a letter to U.S. House Homeland Security Chairman Bennie Thompson, D-Miss.
Department of Homeland Security officials told Congress on Wednesday that the 670-mile fence might not be completed this year and that it was $400 million over budget because of increased fuel and steel costs and limited labor availability.
The Bush administration had hoped to finish the fence this year, and about 340 miles are built so far. Congress so far has approved some $2.6 billion for fence construction.
Many Texas border communities have opposed the fence, filing lawsuits to prevent the barrier from being built in environmentally sensitive areas, on private property and in areas where it could disrupt farming.
El Paso County Commissioner Veronica Escobar said taxpayer money would be more wisely used to help Americans struggling in the sagging economy.
U.S. Rep. Silvestre Reyes, D-El Paso, said the request for more money proves the project will continue to waste taxpayer money. He called the fence a "failed approach" to border security.
"We should be investing in more boots on the ground and in technologies that will help secure our borders and our ports of entry," Reyes said.
El Paso's business community is not opposed to fencing, per se, said Greater El Paso Chamber of Commerce President Richard Dayoub. Their position is that border security should be a part of a comprehensive plan to overhaul immigration in the U.S.
Fencing off the borders, Dayoub said, is neither economically nor logistically feasible.
"It needs to simply to be used as a tool," he said.
http://www.elpasotimes.com/newupdated/ci_10430287